基于高质高效的西南丘陵山区机械化生产模式评价
基于高质高效的西南丘陵山区机械化生产模式评价
刘鹏伟1,2杨敏丽1,2张小军3林嘉豪1,2彭维钦4王志琴1,2
1. 中国农业大学工学院2. 中国农业大学中国农业机械化发展研究中心3. 四川省农机化技术推广总站4. 重庆市农业机械化技术推广总站
摘要:针对西南丘陵山区机械化生产体系不完善、生产模式复杂多样、缺乏系统评价等问题,以农业经营主体为研究对象,从规模适度-生产高效-生态友好等角度构建“农田+农机+农艺+信息”四融合的西南丘陵山区机械化生产系统及模式评价体系,包含农田宜机化、适度规模经营、农机配备质量、农机装备智能化程度、农机生产效益和耕地健康6维度及15个三级指标。应用层次分析法和CRITIC法确定权重;以农田禀赋为基础、机械装备为核心、规模化效益为导向选取西南地区小麦/玉米机械化生产4种典型模式进行评价比较。结果表明:普通农户关键环节机械化生产模式(M1)下地块较小且地势起伏大,机具只能使用小型、低效率机械;化肥与农药施用量高于标准值,其经营规模与发展模式不可持续;家庭农场带状复合种植机械化生产模式(M2)下实现农田连片经营与田间生产全程机械化,然而带状复合种植收获机具技术尚不成熟,导致模式整体作业效率低于合作社模式,但该模式可提高土地利用率、实现粮食增产,适宜在家庭农场中推广;合作社“全程机械化+数字化”生产模式(M3)下,大中型机械在宜机化改造后的农田中充分发挥作业效率和燃油效率优势,同时产后干燥与初加工处理提升粮食质量和效益,实现了产前、产中、产后全过程机械化,此外数字化管理系统有效提升农业管理和机具使用效率,该模式适宜在丘陵山区合作社及部分家庭农场中大力推广;大型合作社种养循环全程机械化生产模式(M4)在全程高效机械赋能的基础上,实现了种养结合的农业产业链,合作社生产的青贮秸秆销售给奶牛场做加工饲料,奶牛产出的有机肥供给合作社进行循环利用,该模式实现生态经济耕作,适宜在部分养殖大县中进行推广。4种模式的综合评价值分别为:0.31、0.67、0.86和0.79,排序从大到小依次为:M3、M4、M2、M1;评价结果符合现实情况,该指标体系能够客观评价各机械化生产模式特点,可为西南丘陵山区各经营主体机械化生产模式选择及改进提供理论基础。
Evaluation of mechanized production model based on high quality and high efficiency in southwestern hilly mountainous area
LIU Pengwei1,2 YANG Minli1,2 ZHANG Xiaojun3 LIN Jiahao1,2 PENG Weiqin4 WANG Zhiqin1,2
1. College of Engineering, China Agricultural University 2. China Agricultural Mechanization Development Research Center, China Agricultural University 3. Sichuan Provincial General Station of Agricultural Mechanization Technology Promotion 4. Chongqing General Station of Agricultural Mechanization Technology Promotion
Abstract: Aiming at the problems of imperfect mechanized production system, complex and diversified production modes, and lack of systematic evaluation in the hilly mountainous areas in Southwest China, the research object is the agricultural management subject, and the mechanized production system and mode evaluation system in the hilly mountainous areas in Southwest China, which includes farmland suitable for mechanization, high efficiency of production, and ecological friendliness, is constructed from the perspectives of scale moderation, high efficiency of production and ecological friendliness. The evaluation system of mechanized production system and model in the hilly mountainous areas of Southwest China was constructed from the perspectives of "farmland + agricultural machinery + agronomy + information", including six dimensions and 15 three-level indexes, including the mechanization of farmland, the appropriate scale of operation, the quality of agricultural machinery, the degree of intelligence of agricultural machinery and equipment, the production efficiency of agricultural machinery and the health of farmland. Hierarchical analysis and CRITIC method were applied to determine the weights; four typical models of mechanized wheat/corn production in Southwest China were selected for evaluation and comparison on the basis of farmland endowment, machinery and equipment as the core, and scale efficiency as the guide. The results show that: under the key link mechanized production mode (M1) of common farmers, the plots are small and the terrain is undulating, and only small and low-efficiency machinery can be used; the application of chemical fertilizers and pesticides is higher than the standard value, and the scale of its operation and the development mode is not sustainable; under the mechanized production mode (M2) of family farms' strip composite planting, the continuous operation of the farmland and the whole mechanization of the production of fields are realized, however, the strip composite planting and harvesting machinery technology is still immature, and the mechanization is not yet mature. Harvesting equipment technology is still immature, resulting in the overall operating efficiency of the model is lower than the cooperative model, but the model can improve land utilization and achieve increased food production, which is suitable for the promotion of family farms; Cooperative "full mechanization + digital" production model (M3), large and medium-sized machinery in the appropriate mechanization of transformed farmland to give full play to the advantages of operating efficiency and fuel efficiency, while yielding In the "whole process mechanization + digitalization" production mode (M3), large and medium-sized machinery gives full play to the advantages of operational efficiency and fuel efficiency in the farmland after mechanization transformation, and at the same time, the post-production drying and primary processing treatment improves the quality and efficiency of grain, realizing the mechanization of the whole process of pre-production, production and post-production, and in addition, the digital management system effectively improves the efficiency of agricultural management and use of machinery, which is suitable to be vigorously promoted in the cooperatives of the hilly mountainous areas and some of the family farms. On the basis of high efficiency machinery, it realizes the agricultural industry chain combining planting and raising, the silage straw produced by cooperatives is sold to dairy farms for processing feed, and the organic fertilizer produced by dairy cows is supplied to cooperatives for recycling, which realizes ecological and economic farming, and is suitable for popularization in part of the big counties of farming. the comprehensive evaluation values of the four models are 0.31, 0.67, 0.86 and 0.79 respectively, and the rankings are, from big to small The evaluation results are in line with the reality, and the index system can objectively evaluate the characteristics of each mechanized production mode, which can provide a theoretical basis for the selection and improvement of mechanized production modes of each business subject in the hilly mountainous areas of southwest China.
Keywords:Hilly mountainous area; Agricultural mechanization; Production mode; Evaluation system.
链接:

